Substitute for Whole and Ground Cloves
There are a few options to recreate the flavor of cloves
Cloves provide a distinctive aromatic flavor for a variety of dishes from all over the world. They're the buds of an evergreen tree in the myrtle family, fittingly named syzygium aromaticum. The word "clove" comes from the French word "clou" which means "nail," since the shape of a clove resembles that of a small nail or tack.
When a recipe calls for whole or ground cloves, and you don't have any on hand, just grab one of these simple substitutes. They'll give you the flavor you're after.
Use one teaspoon of whole cloves in place of 3/4 teaspoon of ground cloves (so that's 1-1/3 times as many whole cloves as ground cloves).
If you don't have whole cloves, you can also substitute the ground cloves called for in the recipe with an equal amount of allspice.
Out of allspice, too? Not a problem. Just use nutmeg or cinnamon instead (or do a 50-50 blend of the two, if you have both). Cinnamon isn't quite as sweet as cloves, so if you're making a dessert recipe, you may want to add a splash of vanilla extract to sweeten it a bit.
Whole Clove Substitute
Use 3/4 teaspoon of ground cloves in place of one teaspoon of whole cloves (so that's 1/4 teaspoon fewer ground cloves for each teaspoon of whole cloves that you're replacing).
Note that using ground cloves in place of whole cloves will change the color and flavor of your recipe somewhat. When you use whole cloves, you usually remove them before serving the food/drink, so they impart a more subtle flavor and don't contribute much to the color of the finished dish.
If your recipe calls for poking whole cloves into meat or oranges, you'll probably want to stick with the real thing. There's just no substitution for the dramatic presentation that whole cloves create.
Taste of Cloves
Cloves have a sweet, warm flavor, and are intensely aromatic. They pair well with allspice, cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla and citrus flavors, and work just as well in savory dishes as in sweet dishes.
Cloves are used in recipes throughout the world. You'll find them in meat dishes and curries, flavoring fruits and marinades and even in drinks, like wine and cider.
They're traditionally associated with dishes served in the fall and winter, such as pumpkin pie, pumpkin soup, turkey and other poultry dishes.
How to Save Money on Whole Cloves
If you're hesitant to buy whole cloves because of the price, consider purchasing them at an international grocery store.
They're used heavily in Indian food, so you can usually find them at a good price at an Indian or Asian grocery store.
The bulk bins at your local grocery or health foods store are another option. They're great because they allow you to buy just what you need and not a clove more. If none of these is an option in your area, ordering online is probably your best bet.
Tip: Grind whole cloves just before you use them to get the best flavor and fragrance. A mortar and pestle or coffee/spice grinder make quick work of the grinding.